top of page


Custom Decorated Cookies
  • In general, we require a minimum order of 2 dozen cookies so that we are able to use an entire batch of dough. However, if you would like to order less than that, please contact us. We may be able to accommodate a smaller order.  

  • Please contact us for a quote.  

Sample Packs
  • If you want to try our cookies before making a larger purchase, we do offer sample packs. 

  • Each pack has two cookies. 

  • Sample packs may require a lead time of two weeks if we are super busy. 

  • Available as a one time purchase per customer.

  • Contact us for pricing. 

Paint Your Own (PYO) Cookies
  • PYO cookies are available for order throughout the year. 

  • There is a minimum order of six cookies. 

  • Each cookie comes with a paint brush and paint palette. 

  • Individual cookies are sometimes offered during holidays (ex: Christmas, Easter, Thanksgiving, etc...). Follow us on Facebook and Instagram for additional details. 

Dipper Kits 
  • Yummy mini cookies with an icing/sprinkle dip!

DIY Cookie Kits
  • Each kit includes 6 cookies, three different colors of icing, matching sprinkles and instructions. 

  • Follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter for more information about availability 

Chocolate Confections
  • Chocolate chip cookies
  • Chocolate covered pretzels and more!
  • Current flavors: vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, confetti, lemon, & pineapple
  • We offer a variety of buttercream frosting flavors and cream cheese frosting too! 
  • Contact use today for pricing
Cake Pops/Cakesicles/Cake Balls
(Menu may change subject to ingredient availability)
  • Current Flavors (one flavor for TWO dozen): 
    1. Apple Butter 

    2. Apple Cider Donut

    3. Apple Cider Donut Oreo

    4. Apple Pie Snaps 

    5. Blueberry Banana Bread

    6. Blueberry Fritter

    7. Blueberry Mojito (non-alcoholic)

    8. Blueberry Pop Tart

    9. Blueberry Scone

    10. Blueberry Shortcake

    11. Boo Berry Cake

    12. Brown Sugar Pop Tart

    13. Brownie

    14. Brownie (with caramel chips, pecans and chocolate chips)

    15. Butter Pecan Banana Bread

    16. Buttermilk Birthday Cake

    17. Butterscotch Blondie

    18. Chai Oatmeal Cookie

    19. Cherry Dr. Pepper

    20. Chocolate

    21. Cinnamon Vanilla Bean

    22. Cookies & Cream

    23. Cookies & Scream M&M

    24. Count Chocula

    25. Dark Chocolate Coconut

    26. Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter

    27. Drumstick (Ice Cream Inspired)

    28. Franken Berry

    29. Frosty (Ice Cream Inspired)

    30. Funfetti

    31. Georgia Peach Pound Cake

    32. Half Baked (Ice Cream Inspired)

    33. Java Chip Oreo

    34. Krispy Kreme Donut

    35. Lemon Blueberry Oreo

    36. Lemon Pound Cake

    37. Lemon Strawberry Yogurt Pound Cake

    38. Lemon Vanilla Bean

    39. Lemonade

    40. Limoncello & Raspberry

    41. Maple Bacon

    42. Maple Oatmeal Cookie

    43. Marshmallow Oreo

    44. Mexican Coffee

    45. Mocha Frappuccino

    46. Nutter Butter Butterfinger 

    47. Orange Juice

    48. Orange Julius

    49. Orange Sherbet

    50. Oreo Boo! Bar

    51. Peach Cobbler

    52. Peach Ice Cream

    53. Phish Food (Ice Cream Inspired)

    54. Pina Colada Streusel

    55. Pineapple Orange

    56. Pumpkin Cream Cheese

    57. Pumpkin Donut

    58. Pumpkin Pie

    59. Pumpkin Spice Cheerios

    60. Pumpkin Spice Cinnamon Rolls

    61. Pumpkin Spice Coffee Creamer

    62. Pumpkin Spice Kit Kat

    63. Pumpkin Spice Latte

    64. Pumpkin Streusel

    65. Pumpkin Vanilla Bean

    66. Raspberry Lemon Cream Cheese

    67. Red Velvet

    68. Salted Caramel Brownie Oreo

    69. Snickerdoodle Hot Cocoa

    70. Snow Cream (Ice Cream Inspired)

    71. Spiced Caramel Apple Cider

    72. Strawberry Peach

    73. Strawberry Shortcake

    74. Tagalongs 

    75. Thin Mint

    76. Triple Chocolate

    77. Vanilla

    78. Whatchamacallit (Candy Bar Inspired)

    79. White Chocolate Raspberry

  • White chocolate or milk chocolate coating
Coffee And Cocoa Drops
(Menu may change subject to ingredient availability)
  • Current Flavors:
     1. Traditional Cocoa
     2. Dark Chocolate Raspberry
     3. Reese Cup​
     4. White Chocolate Pumpkin Spice
     5. Salted Caramel Pumpkin Spice
     6. White Chocolate
     7. Andes Mint
     8. Salted Caramel
     9. Snikerdoodle
    10. Unicorn Poop
    11. S'mores
    12. French Vanilla Latte
    13. Caramel Apple Cider
    14. Dark Chocolate Espresso
    15. Hazelnut Latte
    16. Caramel Latte
    17. Cafe Mocha
    18. Strawberry Supreme
    19. Cereal Bomb (Flavors Vary)
    20. Mexican Hot Chocolate
    21. White Chocolate Peppermint
    22. Dark Chocolate Peppermint
    23. Double Dark Chocolate
    24. Butterscotch
Creamer Drops
  • Sold in packs of (4), our creamer drops are totally customizable. 

  • Step 1, you choose the shell (white chocolate, milk chocolate, or salted caramel).

  • Step 2, choose your creamer (French Vanilla, Vanilla Caramel, Caramel Macchiato, Chocolate Creme, Hazelnut, Caramel Latte, or Cinnamon French Toast). NOTE: Creamers are in powder form. Liquid creamers would ruin the chocolate shell and they are not shelf stable.

  • Step 3, choose your drizzle (white chocolate, milk chocolate, or salted caramel)

S'more Packs
  • Two graham crackers, chocolate and a personalized marshmallow packed and ready to make a yummy s'more treat. 

Cotton Candy
  • We offer pre-packaged containers, bags, and other fun things like push pops, candy cones, candy pops, and more.

Other Items
  • Brownies

  • Rice Krispy Treats

  • Hot Milk Cakes

  • Seasonal cookies are offered throughout the year and are priced separately from custom cookies. These items will be advertised on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. 

All custom orders will require at least two weeks of advanced notice. Larger orders will require more time. 
Payment, in full, is required to reserve an order date. 
Welcome to The Well-Dressed Cookie, LLC!
I purchased my first decorated sugar cookies in 2020 during the national COVID quarantine. Each one was a handheld work of art. As a bonus, they tasted great too! Intrigued by the process, my daughters and I started reading blogs and watching YouTube videos about cookie decorating. It wasn't long before I was buying supplies and ingredients so we could make our first batch. While I will admit that the first attempts weren't masterpieces, we were hooked. As time has passed, we have added several more treats to our menu.  Our handcrafted treats are an excellent addition to any occasion or a special treat! 
We are a home based business in
New Market, MD. 
Let us know how we may serve you!
FOOD ALLERGY NOTICE: Although an allergen may not be listed in our ingredients, please note that our treats are made in a kitchen containing known food allergens, including, but not limited to: wheat, eggs, milk, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. If you have any questions or concerns about allergies, please let us know before placing your order.​Treats are made by a cottage food business that is not subject to Maryland’s food safety regulations. 

About Us

bottom of page